Sunday, October 25, 2009

7195: U.S. Census’ Colorful Spending Plan.

From Advertising Age…

U.S. Census Allots $145 Million to Reach Out to Minorities
Government Bureau Works With Ethnic Shops to Build Trust, Allay Fears

By Laurel Wentz

NEW YORK ( -- Multicultural experts expect the 2010 census to boost ad spending toward minority groups as awareness of their numbers grows—but first, they have to be accurately counted.

To overcome immigration-status fears and general mistrust of the government, the U.S. Census Bureau is allocating the majority—estimated at $145 million—of its $300 million paid-media budget to multicultural audiences. It’s working with five ethnic shops, plus general-market agency DraftFCB’s Puerto Rico office to cover its territory. Their ad efforts to reach the hardest-to-count U.S. inhabitants will kick off in January

Separately, Spanish-language broadcasters Univision Communications and Telemundo have already started aggressive public-service campaigns with the theme “Be counted” and are integrating their own messages about the value of the census for the Latino community into all their platforms. Univision is building off its previous push to mobilize Hispanics to apply for citizenship—1.4 million did—and to register to vote last year, said Cesar Conde, president of Univision Networks. “We’ve put the gang together again [for the census campaign].”

Univision anchor Maria Elena Salinas, part of the earlier effort, appears in Univision’s census ads explaining, “If they don’t count us, we won’t count.”

Don Browne, president of NBC Universal-owned Telemundo Communications Group, pointed out that Nielsen will use census figures to allocate its meters, adding more Hispanics where the Latino population is growing rapidly. “If you’re in the Hispanic media business, this will dramatically affect ratings and growth in Spanish-language media,” he said.

Big shift
The census will also highlight demographic changes, such as U.S.-born Hispanics surpassing immigrants as the biggest source of Hispanic growth, and will encourage marketers to shift more dollars to target Hispanics, he said.

GlobalHue, the biggest multicultural agency, is handling census ads targeted at Hispanics and blacks. For multicultural audiences, agencies are picking from the five mind-sets identified by DraftFCB that are most relevant for their groups.

Luciana Gomez, the GlobalHue VP-group account director in charge of the Spanish-language census campaign, said Hispanics tend to fall into the “head nodders,” “insulated” and “unacquainted” categories. The last group consists mostly of recent immigrants unfamiliar with the census and suspicious of what the government will do with the information.

Ms. Gomez said copy testing indicated that a focus on children and their future, and how the census influences funding and helps their community grow would work best for all three groups. “Hispanics will go through a lot of sacrifice for their children, and we’re just asking for ten minutes of their time,” she said.

For the black community, “there’s knowledge of the census, they just haven’t seen evidence it makes a difference,” said GlobalHue VP-account director Damien Reid.

Beyond Hispanic
Another Hispanic shop, D Exposito & Partners, is responsible for local media, digital and PR for Hispanic audiences. The agency also came up with the creative concept for all audiences, including the general market, for the crucial phase when census workers go door-to-door in pursuit of non-responders who ignore the census questionnaire and follow-up mailing. That message is: “Open the doors to the census, and the census will open doors for you.”

Of the estimated $82 million destined for paid ethnic media—although those numbers could change—about $28 million would go to Hispanic media, $24.5 million to black media and $18 million to Asian-American media. Another $12 million would target other multicultural audiences, from American Indians to Arabic speakers. For the first time, the census website will be fully bilingual in English and Spanish, and will include assistance guides in 59 other languages.

Allied Media Group has a tough task in reaching speakers of Arabic, Russian, Polish, Ukrainian, Armenian and Farsi, many of whom fled their nations out of fear of the government, said Account Manager Paul Young.

But Asian-American agency IW Group’s job is the most complex of all the census agencies. Although Asian Americans only account for about 4% of the U.S. population, there are so many different language groups that advertisers often stretch their budgets by casting generic pan-Asian actors in ads and do voice-overs for different languages.

“We’re in uncharted territory,” said IW Account Director Charmaine David. Her agency is doing 24 TV commercials—one spot for each of the three census phases, in eight different languages, plus 36 radio spots in 12 languages and 39 print ads in 13 languages.


HustleKnocker said...

Here's what makes me nervous:

"For multicultural audiences, agencies are picking from the five mind-sets identified by DraftFCB that are most relevant for their groups."


DraftFCB has almost zero experience dealing with consumers of color, yet here are several ethnic agencies being forced to do what?

Pick cards from some predetermined deck dealt to them by Draft. I saw better odds a couple weeks ago when I was in Vegas.

Apparently GlobalHue and crew aren't capable of determining mindsets or points of commonality, interest and barriers for the communities they target.

no doubt this will be followed by some "strategically universal" work.

So even as the US continues to fracture and evolve into a more nuanced mosaic, the homogenized BS approach used to reach them will continue on.

long live The Hustle.

HighJive said...

Also note the paid media figures in the final chart are "subject to change" — and it's likely not Obama's change we can believe in.