
Advertising
Age reported on the increased registration-only events at Cannes Lions International
Festival of Creativity, which especially frustrated newer attendees denied
access beyond velvet ropes.
Um, Cannes
has always embraced exclusivity—marginalizing people based on status at White
advertising agencies, country of origin, gender, sexual identity, race and
ethnicity, etc.
Hell, even
the Omnicom
Inclusion Breakfast was an exclusive affair.
As for
registration-only issues, don’t forget the initiatives
to ban registered
sex offenders.
Registration-only
events make Cannes feel less democratic and overly programmed
By E.J.
Schultz, Ewan Larkin, and Brian Bonilla
To thrive at
Cannes this year, you needed two things: a fan and your name on countless
registration lists. It was the hottest Cannes in memory and also perhaps the
most exclusive one.
While the Cannes
Lions International Festival of Creativity has seen a steady rise in roped-off
events, this year it seemed to reach a tipping point. The beach and harbor were
again dominated by activations that required registration, including Stagwell’s
Sport Beach, Amazon Port, Spotify Beach and others. This year, there was a
noticeable encroachment inland, with multiple cafes overtaken by vendors and
agencies, which used them to conduct invite-only programming or hold client
meetings, effectively shutting them off from average festival-goers.
One big change
from last year: Caffe Roma, a normally welcoming spot in the shadow of the
Palais, was overtaken by Creative Artists Agency, where people guarding the
entrance turned away anyone not on the list.
“People without
a pay-to-play space are having to get real inventive about where to eat and
meet this year, given the sprawling nature of branded spaces—they’ve exploded,”
said Oliver McAteer, head of development and partner at Mischief @ No Fixed
Address. “It feels like no inch of Cannes has been left untouched. Quiet
restaurants you could sneak away to and take a meeting or grab a rare bite are
now an AI firm you’ve never heard of. AI is likely the reason I am sunburned.”
The situation
added more fire to the long-running debate over whether Cannes Lions has lost
its appeal as a community gathering for creatives of all stripes, especially
those without industry connections.
Take it from
Fernando Machado, the chief brand officer of Chipotle, who has been coming to
Cannes since he was a rising marketer at Unilever. “It was just the Palais,” he
said in an interview this week, referring to the festival’s traditional home
venue. “I would buy two cereal bars, two Gatorades” and “be there for the day.”
He referred to this year’s festival as being filled with RSVP lists and Cannes
“bouncers.”
“It makes it
less democratic, right?” Machado said. “I’ve been in the industry for long now,
and I know a lot of people, so I think it’s easy for me to get in.” But
Fernando from 15 years ago would likely be shut out, he added.
Leeann Leahy,
CEO of The Via Agency, shared a similar perspective. “It feels more like a ‘No,
you can’t’ festival with all of its closed doors and over-programmed venues.
And I have always loved the discovery of this festival,” Leahy said, noting
that it took her “an hour to find a cafe that wasn’t taken over by some brand
somewhere.”
Frances
Webster, CEO of Walrus, said she had to take a breakfast meeting at the Gutter
Bar, which is typically popular for late-night drinks, because so many Cannes
restaurants were rented out this year.
WPP’s VML took
over Beryte, a Lebanese restaurant, while tech brand InMobi took over another
eatery to promote Glance, an intelligent shopping agent.
There was also
some disgruntlement about the Carlton Hotel, which often serves as a watering
hole for delegates beginning at night and extending into the early hours of the
morning. Attendees reported being turned away by security unless they were
meeting with somebody already inside, and voiced complaints about the hotel
charging $100 per person to sit at a table. Tom Morrissy, chief growth officer
of independent media agency Noble People, said such tactics hurt “the history
and spirit of the festival.”
How the
scorching heat affected Cannes
Of course, with
scorching temperatures, drinking late into the night was not always the best
idea. A historic heat wave gripped France for most of the week. The most common
sight on the Croisette: People draped in event lanyards and wristbands holding
fans. Nicola Mendelsohn, head of Meta’s global business group, summed it up
quite nicely at a panel on WPP’s rooftop near the end of the week, suggesting
her Oura ring “thinks I’m dead.”
The heatwave
“made every indoor session a refuge and outdoor activations a genuine endurance
test,” Lindsay Slaby, founder of marketing consultancy Sunday Dinner, wrote in
her Cannes recap for clients. She noted that it “probably contributed to the
intimacy premium: small dinners, air-conditioned villas, the sessions with 21
people at the art hotel beat everything happening at Croisette scale.”
She also
observed that the “old Cannes energy was genuinely porous,” referring to past
festivals of “creative directors running into clients at the Gutter Bar at 2
a.m.,” and “serendipitous collisions that turned into briefs.”
The corporate
sprawl beyond the Palais is a physical manifestation of how Cannes continues to
evolve into a business conference as much as it is a creativity festival. Ad
tech players, who began descending on Cannes years ago, are now joined by a
growing number of consultancies. Boston Consulting Group upped its Cannes
presence starting about four years ago and this year ran its BCG House along
the Croisette, with programming on topics such as organizational transformation
and the path from CMO to CEO.
“Marketing is
one of our biggest topics for us commercially,” said Jessica Apotheker, BCG’s
CMO, managing director and senior partner. “It’s just a great opportunity to
engage with marketing leaders. We will share some more thought leadership,
connect with the right people, and also connect with the technical system.”
Cannes Lions
itself is leaning into executive involvement. For the second year in a row, it
hosted a Global CEO Forum. This year, the closed-door session at the Carlton
ran on the festival’s opening day and was “strictly limited to 50 personally
invited global CEOs,” according to its website, with McKinsey listed as a “lead
insight partner.”
Still, there
does appear to be a concerted effort to preserve the festival’s original
creative spirit. Ciaran McCarthy, VP of brand and global advertising at
Microsoft, told Ad Age on Monday that his whole team was in the South of France
this week, spending lots of time walking the work and attending award shows.
“I hope others are doing the same,” McCarthy
said. “It’d be a shame to come here and not.”