Advertising Age reported Sears and mcgarrybowen decided to “part ways”—which is code for agency termination, regardless of mcgarrybowen’s contention that they resigned the account. Sorry, but mcgarrybowen’s sycophantic personality makes it impossible to deliberately relinquish billings. The advertiser and White advertising agency were actually a perfect pairing of mediocrity and meh. Fortunately, there’s an endless pool of hackneyed White advertising agencies ready and willing to accommodate the retail dinosaur.
McGarryBowen and Sears Part Ways
Move Happens In Midst Of Massive Holding Company Consolidation
By Maureen Morrison
McGarryBowen and Sears Holdings are parting ways, Ad Age has learned.
The shop has been working on the Sears brand since it won the account in 2011.
The split comes as the retailer is in the midst of a massive holding-company level procurement-led consolidation that began in November. The review has been delayed, according to people familiar with it, with no requests for proposal being distributed yet. These people said that the company has been meeting with all the major ad agency holding companies and still plans to send RFPs to those it wants to go to the next step. The review is slated to be completed in May.
McGarryBowen, part of Dentsu Aegis, was in the running in the review, but chose to resign the account, according to people familiar with the matter. In an internal memo sent to the shop’s employees, co-founder Gordon Bowen said that he and the agency’s leadership had decided to part ways with Sears.
Sears has long been described as a demanding client. In 2011, when it was reviewing the Sears brand business that McGarryBowen ultimately won, it upset many agencies when it said that it would own the ideas that agencies pitched. Other people familiar with the marketer have said that the company over years has continued to cut its agency fees.
The agency confirmed that it resigned the account, but declined to elaborate. Representatives for Sears did not have immediate comment. [UPDATE: Bill Kiss, VP-chief digital marketing officer at Sears Holdings, said in a statement that the company thanked McGarryBowen for its work. “Our multifaceted process continues and we are confident we will ultimately select the right agency to support our continued transformation,” he said. “In the interim, we will work with our incumbent agencies to pick up the Sears brand work.”]
On the marketing front, several senior-level executives have left the company, according to people familiar with the business. Imran Jooma, the company’s exec VP and president of marketing, online and financial services, said in December that he was leaving the company.
Sears Holdings has been struggling lately, losing money for 10 straight quarters, closing stores and most recently, laying off about 115 people in corporate earlier this month in an effort to reduce expenses. Sears will report earnings on Thursday.
In March 2014, Havas in Chicago picked up the creative work for Craftsman, Die Hard and Kenmore. Media is handled by Havas, and Interublic’s FCB handles creative for Kmart.
Sears Holdings is the 27th largest marketer in the U.S., according to Ad Age’s DataCenter. In 2013, the Sears brand alone spent $340 million in U.S. measured media, the last full year of available data, according to Kantar Media. Sibling brand Kmart spent $209 million. Kenmore that year had about $21 million in U.S. measured media, while Craftsman has $15 million.
Contributing: Ashley Rodriguez