
Adweek
reported—and provided an update—on the exclusivity at Cannes Lions
International Festival of Creativity, where culturally clueless controversy
erupted after the awards show initially assembled a predominately White
Brazilian jury pool.
Cannes Lions officials
quickly rejiggered the invitations for greater Black representation, spewing
the standard clichéd and contrived apologies. The unconsciously biased bullshit
from Cannes Lions
CEO Simon Cook included, “[W]e are still far from where we want to be…I
wholeheartedly recognize there is more work to be done…”
The
scenario presented a host of hilarious hypocrisies and hijinks such as:
•
Brazil—the country often accused of submitting scam campaigns—now adds
suspicious jury selection to its creative character defects.
•
The premier advertising awards show perfectly reflects Adland by perpetuating
prejudiced pranks—and can’t even craft an original excuse for their
discriminatory deeds.
•
The Adweek article was illustrated with a flag of Brazil image (depicted above).
For diversity at Cannes, it would be more appropriate—and symbolically clever—to
raise a White flag.
Nearly
All-White Brazil Delegation for Cannes Lions Spurs Uproar
Agency members penned an open letter
to Lions CEO Simon Cook
By Chris Ariens
Update:
On May 13, a week after this story was published, we received this update:
“Cannes
Lions have taken immediate action and invited five black Brazilian creatives to
join their 2022 juries,” said Andre Chaves of advocacy group Papel &
Caneta. “In addition, they will provide a speaking slot at the festival to give
a voice to black creative talent on the global stage.”
The
additions come following a meeting members of the advocacy groups had with
Cannes Lions CEO Simon Cook earlier this week. Following next month’s festival,
Cook also plans to visit Brazil to meet with organizations that can help the
festival forge better relationships with the wider Black creative community.
Original story: A collective of Brazilian creatives, supported by a vocal
ensemble of diversity champions, has penned an open letter to Cannes Lions CEO
Simon Cook questioning the choice of its jurors from Brazil, with only one
Black creative out of 24 names.
The
group called on the Lions to consider proportional diversity as a criteria for
jury selection. The move has been supported by industry leaders like Cindy
Gallop and Kat Gordon of the 3% Conference.
“We
are committed to having more representative juries—but we are still far from
where we want to be,” Cook said today in response to the letter. “This year, we
have missed the mark on the selection of jurors in Brazil.”
“I’m
glad to hear that the Cannes organization recognizes that their team failed in
the selection of jurors in Brazil, but I expect more changes,” Andre Chaves,
founder of São Paulo’s Papel & Caneta, an advocacy group working on behalf
of creatives, and one of the authors of the open letter, told Adweek. “It makes
no sense to have only one Black person out of 24 jurors. And if it did, it just
goes to show that there is something very wrong with the selection criteria.”
Gabriela
Rodrigues, another voice behind the open letter and head of impact and culture
at agency SOKO, told Adweek: “It is urgent for the Cannes Lions festival to
rethink its jury selection criteria. We want less political factors and more
fairness in the criteria. We want space for the bright Black people who exist
in the Brazilian market—and also outside Brazil—to have a real chance.”
“I
wholeheartedly recognize there is more work to be done at an individual country
level,” Cook added. “The Cannes Lions shortlisting jury will be announced next
week, and we will ensure better representation globally—and at a local level,
particularly in Brazil.”
Cannes
Lions said its juror diversity efforts have led to an increase of Black
representation from 8% in 2021 to 13% this year. Cook thanked Chaves, Rodrigues
and their group for drawing attention to the problem, adding, “we’re committed
to our juries being more representative of society, year on year.”
With
a population of 215 million, more than half of the Brazilian population (56%) identify
as Black, according to the Brazilian Institute of Geography and Statistics
(IBGE).