
Advertising Age
published performative PR from BRIDGE, an
enterprise that the trade publication labeled as follows: “an independent trade
organization pushing for diversity, equity, and inclusion in marketing.”
Not sure why BRIDGE would
be deemed independent, given its “Leaders”
include a Board of Directors defined as “the governing body of BRIDGE, composed of a combination of
DE&I leaders, business leaders, and other C-suite leaders in organizations
who are driving the change agenda internally.” That is, the board features up
to 30 individuals whose professional roles cover Chief Marketing Officers, CEOs,
and Human Heat Shields from White advertising agencies. Conspicuously
absent are any legitimate ad agency leaders—to twist a phrase, “Where are all the White people?”
How can one
assume independence in relationships firmly rooted in codependence? Hell, it’s
almost laughable that these folks—while likely well-intentioned and respectable
corporate citizens—cannot offer evidence to prove they’re driving the change
agenda internally, externally, or in any dimension. This especially applies to
the White advertising agencies, where annual confessions confirm firmly
established and perpetuated systemic racism.
All of which
makes BRIDGE sorta offensive. If the representatives from brands like Campbell’s,
Colgate-Palmolive, H&R Block, and Unilever were honestly dedicated to change, they
would burn their bridges with Adland representatives such as Publicis Groupe and WPP. After all, the co-conspiratorial
unions symbolize hypocrisy of the highest order.
BRIDGE is
part of a thoroughly damaged infrastructure.
Brands Pilot DE&I Program To Foster Companywide
Inclusion
After finding many brands’ social posts were 23 years
behind on representation, DE&I trade org BRIDGE created a program that is
being piloted by Campbell Soup Co., Condé Nast and Sephora
By Lindsay Rittenhouse
The majority of the top 50 brands that post content
to social media are 23 years behind in terms of reflecting the actual racial
makeup of America, based on U.S. Census data, according to a recent analysis by
BRIDGE, an independent trade organization for progressing diversity, equity and
inclusion in marketing.
That analysis was used as the jumping-off
point for BRIDGE’s new Inclusion Maturity Assessment and Capability Building
Program (dubbed IMAX for short), which it is launching to help brands implement
inclusion as a business practice across their entire organizations, internally
and externally, to drive growth.
“Our whole mission is to move the narrative
of DE&I away from philosophy to operationalizing inclusion as a business
practice because we fundamentally believe that it's the next opportunity for
business growth,” said Sheryl Daija, the founder and CEO of BRIDGE, which is an
acronym for the gaps within belonging, representation, inclusion, diversity and
equity. “Unfortunately, we have seen the attacks that can happen when you’re
talking about philosophy, opinions and beliefs, versus when you have something
that is steeped with the same rigor that other business practices have.”
Marketers including Campbell Soup Co., Condé Nast
and Sephora are piloting the program, which involves evaluating the equities
and inequities that exist for underrepresented communities across companies’
product availability, pricing structures and services. The program starts with
understanding where companies are in terms of their inclusion efforts both
internally and externally—rating them on a maturity scale across 72 business
practices and five dimensions of the workplace and marketplace. Then, a team of
experts works on how to tackle the gaps they identify and implement change for
the companies.
“We were excited about BRIDGE’s IMAX program
as it extends beyond the scope of existing DE&I assessments that are
primarily focused on culture and the workplace to include marketplace actions,”
said Abigail Jacobs, senior VP of brand and integrated marketing, Sephora. “As
a retailer with extensive programs around building equity across our business,
and especially our stores, we’re always working to ensure that our practices
drive positive impact and change.”
The IMAX social media analysis revealed most
brands are 23 years behind in properly reflecting the racial makeup of the U.S.
in social content.
IMAX is led by BRIDGE’s board of directors
and steering committee, as well as an academic team that included Omar
RodrÃguez-Vilá, professor of marketing and director of education at the
Business & Society Institute at Emory University’s Goizueta Business
School; Sundar Bharadwaj, professor of marketing at University of Georgia’s
Terry College of Business; and Dionne Nickerson, assistant professor of
marketing at Indiana University.
The program evaluates DE&I across various
areas of a company including within the organization, their marketing
management processes, commercial practices, communications and advocacy
programs.
“The biggest gap we see is in commercial
practices, in products that are designed specifically to address the needs of
underrepresented communities,” RodrÃguez-Vilá said.
Most companies do not properly measure the
market, RodrÃguez-Vilá said. Currently, they measure the market based on
“‘Where is my current revenue coming from?’ and ‘Who are my biggest customers?
If 80% of my customer base comes from this group, then I go after that group.’
"You’re not looking at the potential
growth that could be embedded in segments that are actually not consuming you,
or are significantly under-consuming you, because you’re not including them in
your offer,” he said.
Each of the 72 business practices being
evaluated in the IMAX program is rated against a “maturity” scale of 70%, which
represents a high level of inclusion.
“Following the assessment, it was awesome to
see that the analysis reinforced many of our business practices were already on
the right track,” Jacobs said. “We have 11 different internal workstreams
focused on different parts of our DE&I journey and have been able to share
these findings and act quickly on integrating them into our current work.”
The IMAX team used artificial intelligence to
do the first part of its research, the social media analysis of the top 50
brands’ content that had people in it, RodrÃguez-Vilá said. "We measured
the diversity of skin tone, diversity of hair type, inclusion of people with
disabilities and diversity of body types.”
In that analysis, Unilever’s Dove rose to the
top and was one of the only brands that was not 23 years behind in terms of
inclusion practices across its social media posts. Dove has done various
campaigns to advocate for underrepresented groups including taking a stand
against race-based hair discrimination.
“I receive a lot of data in my role, but I
have never seen data of this nature that allows us to understand inclusion as a
metric and helps us identify which practices we can share across brands to
create and accelerate even further impact,” said Tish Archie-Oliver, head of
diversity, equity, inclusion and belonging, Unilever U.S., and a BRIDGE Board
member.
Dove declined further comment because it is
not part of the IMAX pilot program.
Still, being inclusive across social media
content is only one sliver of the pie and the IMAX program comes as companies
have downsized their DE&I departments amid economic headwinds.
“The key is not to think of inclusion as a
separate thing,” RodrÃguez-Vilá said. “The first thing you need to tackle is
the business case. There is also a role for a moral case and many leaders need
to be able to articulate that to their employees. This is not just about
selling more stuff. But you need both because, in the absence of a business
case, the moral case is not going to sustain you.”
RodrÃguez-Vilá said what also went into
developing the IMAX program was having chief marketers and chief diversity
officers work closer together than they’re typically used to—both parties are
responsible for evaluating DE&I within the internal organization and in how
the company is showing up in the marketplace. Typically, internal matters were
left to chief diversity officers while marketplace matters were left to chief
marketing officers.
“It unlocks this collaboration that didn’t
exist before,” Daija said. “[Before] it was very siloed. IMAX creates a
collaboration to allow all capabilities and practices to be dependent on each
other, but also to leverage the power of each other.”