Monday, July 18, 2011
9023: O&M’s Multicultural Mumbo-Jumbo.
From The New York Times…
Mosaic Marketing Takes a Fresh Look at Changing Society
By Stuart Elliott
You may not need a weatherman to know which way the wind blows, as Bob Dylan put it, but it seems that Madison Avenue needed a census taker.
As results from the 2010 census continue to be released, the changing demographic makeup of the American consumer market is increasingly a topic for discussion — and action — among advertisers and agencies. One trend to emerge is known as cross-cultural marketing, aimed at a general market that may be more of a mosaic than a melting pot.
Cross-cultural marketing is, as the term suggests, aimed across demographic groups to appeal to consumer similarities rather than differences. By contrast, traditional multicultural marketing is directed at specific demographic groups like Hispanics, African-Americans, Asian-Americans, women or gay and lesbian consumers.
One of the largest global agencies, Ogilvy & Mather Worldwide, has formed a unit, OgilvyCulture, that specializes in cross-cultural marketing. British Airways and Ikea are among the initial clients of the unit, which has also provided consulting services to advertisers like Eastman Kodak, Kimberly-Clark and Unilever.
OgilvyCulture, which had a “soft launch” in November, is to get an official send-off on Monday with a daylong conference, titled “Preparing for the New General Market,” at the Ogilvy & Mather world headquarters on the West Side of Manhattan.
“This starts from the kind of firm we want to be in the future,” said John Seifert, chairman and chief executive of Ogilvy & Mather North America, and is meant to respond to “extraordinary changes.”
“Instead of thinking of discrete segments in a multicultural world,” he said, “we’re saying the new reality is that it’s more of a cross-cultural world, a mash-up of cultures.”
In seeking “deeper understanding of new cross-cultural realities,” Mr. Seifert said, OgilvyCulture is looking to the “diversity and inclusion” employee networks at Ogilvy & Mather, which include Black Diaspora, LatinRed, OgilvyPride, RedLotus and Women’s Leadership.
That is important, Mr. Seifert said, because “if there has been a weakness in the marketing communications industry generally, it’s that the makeup of agencies is not reflective” of the consumers to whom they advertise. (“Red” appears in the names of some employee groups because it is the agency color, and the favorite color of the founder, David Ogilvy.)
OgilvyCulture “represents an effort to build on” the work of those internal organizations “and take it out of the agency as an external-facing agenda,” said Jeffrey Bowman, who heads OgilvyCulture as its practice lead while also serving as director for marketing strategy at Ogilvy & Mather.
“As a practice, its success is dependent on a core group of people making connections internally and externally,” he said. “We’re feeling our way; I’ve said to everyone this is going to be messy for a while.”
Asked about the multicultural approach, as offered by scores of agencies that create campaigns aimed at ethnic and demographic groups, Mr. Bowman said: “I do not intend to market this as an alternative to the specialty agencies. We accept the reality there are some clients who will say, ‘We have a general-market agency and a Hispanic agency.’”
Ogilvy & Mather will still operate multicultural units like OgilvyRojo, which creates ads aimed at Spanish-speaking consumers, and OgilvyNoor, which specializes in building brands that appeal to Muslim consumers.
“We’ve been saying for years there’s a new America,” said Howard Buford, president and chief executive at Prime Access in New York, an agency devoted to marketing to three demographic groups: Hispanic, African-American and lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender (L.G.B.T.) consumers.
“It’s multicultural consumers who are making ‘the new general market,’ why not go to an agency with a long track record of multicultural advertising to do general campaigns?” asked Mr. Buford, who said that Prime Access has produced general-market advertising for Merck and the Time Inc. division of Time Warner.
Donna Morton, director for marketing planning for North America at the British Airways office in New York, said she had hired OgilvyCulture to find innovative ways to promote the airline’s Executive Club loyalty program to the diverse fliers of the United States and Canada.
“Several years ago, we were doing that kind of traditional multicultural marketing, grouping people into segments like seniors and L.G.B.T.,” Ms. Morton said. “The world now is so different; now it’s about becoming part of the culture, building relationships.”
Likewise, Christine Whitehawk, communication manager for the Ikea North America unit of Ikea in Conshohocken, Pa., said, “This to us is the beauty of OgilvyCulture. Although we want to ensure that different audiences are engaging with the brand, we don’t want a bunch of different messages.”
“This is not saying, you need 10 communication platforms,” she said. “It’s saying, let’s look at cross-cultural nuances that could work cross-culturally.”
Among those scheduled to speak at the conference, in addition to Mr. Bowman and Mr. Seifert, are David Burgos, vice president at the Millward Brown unit of WPP and the author of a coming book, “Marketing to the New Majority”; Peter Francese, the founder of American Demographics magazine who is now worldwide demographer and trends analyst at Ogilvy & Mather; Mark López, head of United States Hispanic audience and pan-regional United States sales at Google; Michele Thornton, senior director for multicultural advertising sales at the CNN unit of Time Warner; and Miles Young, worldwide chief executive of Ogilvy & Mather.